MENU
Call (863) 774-4556
Tonmiel Rodriguez - Board Certified Criminal Trial Lawyer
✕
Home
Practice Areas
DUI Defense
Areas We Serve
About
Legal Resources
Legal News & Blog Contact Español Call (863) 774-4556
CALL (863) 774-4556 CHAT WITH US

Arson — Florida § 806.01

Under Florida Statute § 806.01(1), arson of a dwelling is a first-degree felony carrying up to 30 years in prison. Arson of any other structure under § 806.01(2) is a second-degree felony with up to 15 years. Burning property to defraud an insurer is a separate third-degree felony under § 817.233, and if the property is a dwelling, the burning can also be charged as first-degree arson. If the fire was set in a structure where a person was present and someone was injured, the charge may escalate to attempted murder. These prosecutions are built heavily on expert fire investigation testimony, and that testimony is frequently wrong. Much of it rests on junk science that courts are increasingly skeptical of.

What Is Arson Under Florida Law?

Florida § 806.01 defines arson as willfully and unlawfully, or while in the commission of any felony, by fire or explosion, damaging or causing to be damaged any dwelling, structure, or the contents of a dwelling or structure. The statute distinguishes between dwellings (homes, residences, structures designed for lodging) and other structures (commercial buildings, vehicles, outbuildings). The key elements are: (1) a willful and unlawful act (or act committed during a felony), (2) using fire or explosion, and (3) damage to a protected structure or its contents.

What Are the Degrees and Penalties for Arson in Florida?

Charge Statute Degree Max Prison
Arson of a dwelling (structure designed for lodging) § 806.01(1) 1st Degree Felony 30 years
Arson of any other structure § 806.01(2) 2nd Degree Felony 15 years
Burning to defraud insurer § 817.233 3rd Degree Felony 5 years
Arson resulting in bodily harm (§ 806.031) § 806.031 1st Degree Misdemeanor (2nd Degree Felony if great bodily harm) 1 year / $1,000
Arson with person present and injury resulting § 806.01 + § 782 Attempted Murder potential Life

First-degree arson under § 806.01(1) is a Level 8 offense on Florida’s Criminal Punishment Code, scoring 74 points (second-degree arson under § 806.01(2) is Level 7, scoring 56). That alone exceeds the 44-point threshold above which the lowest permissible sentence is prison, and victim injury points push the total higher. A conviction for arson of an occupied dwelling carries the weight of a life-altering felony on every background check, professional license review, and future sentencing proceeding.

What Is Arson of an Occupied Structure or Dwelling in Florida?

Under § 806.01(1), first-degree arson covers any dwelling, whether occupied or not; any structure where people are normally present, such as jails, hospitals, stores, office buildings, churches, or schools during normal hours of occupancy; and any other structure that the defendant knew or had reasonable grounds to believe was occupied by a human being. For that last category, the defendant’s knowledge or reasonable grounds to believe someone was inside is an element, and no first-degree category turns on proof that a person was actually present. If someone inside suffers serious bodily injury or is killed, the State will layer attempted murder (§ 782.04) or felony murder charges on top of the arson charge — creating the potential for life imprisonment.

Is Arson to Defraud an Insurer a Separate Crime in Florida?

Yes — under § 817.233, burning or attempting to burn any insured building, structure, or personal property with intent to defraud the insurer is a third-degree felony, whether or not the property belongs to the defendant. The same fire can also be charged as arson under § 806.01, which is first-degree arson if the property is a dwelling. Insurance fraud arson (or “fraud fire”) does not require that a dwelling be involved — burning a commercial building, vehicle, or outbuilding with intent to collect an insurance claim qualifies. These cases typically involve parallel investigations by both law enforcement and the insurer’s special investigation unit (SIU), and prosecutors often file both arson charges and insurance fraud charges (§ 817.234) simultaneously.

How Is Arson Investigated and What Are the Problems With Fire Investigation Science?

Arson investigations in Florida are conducted by the State Fire Marshal’s Office, local fire investigators, and law enforcement agencies. The investigator’s role is to determine the origin and cause of the fire — and when the cause is determined to be “incendiary” (intentionally set), that finding becomes the foundation of the criminal case. The problem is that fire investigation science has a significant history of error.

The National Academy of Sciences’ landmark 2009 report “Strengthening Forensic Science in the United States” identified fire investigation as an area where much of the claimed scientific basis for identifying arson was unsupported by peer-reviewed research. Indicators that investigators historically called “proof of arson” — pour patterns, alligator char, crazed glass, low burn points — have been shown by controlled burn studies to occur in accidental fires as well. The Innocence Project has documented dozens of arson convictions based on junk science. I retain independent fire investigators and fire science experts in arson cases and aggressively challenge the reliability of the State’s investigation methodology under Daubert.

What Are the Best Defenses to Arson Charges in Florida?

Was the Fire Accidental Rather Than Intentionally Set?

Accidental fire is the most fundamental defense in any arson case. Electrical faults, appliance malfunctions, smoking materials, unattended candles, and children playing with fire are all documented causes of residential and commercial fires that are sometimes misclassified as arson. The State’s arson determination is only as reliable as its investigation — and when the investigation used outdated methodology or failed to consider accidental causes, the science behind the arson determination can be challenged under Daubert. A qualified independent fire investigation expert can identify investigative errors that the prosecution’s expert overlooked or ignored.

Was the Fire Investigation Methodology Reliable?

Under Florida’s Daubert standard (§ 90.702), expert testimony on fire cause and origin must be based on sufficient facts and data, reliable methodology, and proper application of that methodology to the facts of the case. When a fire investigator relies on “indicators” that modern burn science has discredited — low burn points, pour patterns, irregular fire patterns — a Daubert motion can challenge the admissibility of the arson opinion entirely. Without the expert opinion that the fire was intentionally set, the State has no arson case. I scrutinize the investigative methodology in every arson case and retain independent fire scientists to evaluate the State’s conclusions.

Did the Defendant Actually Set the Fire?

Identification and proximity evidence are critical in arson cases where the defendant disputes involvement. Physical evidence placing the defendant at the scene, accelerant detection on clothing or hands, cell phone location data, surveillance footage, and witness testimony are all used to establish the defendant’s connection to the fire. Each of these evidence types has vulnerabilities. Accelerant evidence must be collected and preserved properly — chain of custody failures can render it inadmissible. Cell phone data shows location within a range, not at a specific address. Witness credibility in arson cases (often involving co-conspirators, former partners, or business rivals) is frequently impeachable.

Was the Intent to Defraud an Insurer Provable?

In insurance fraud arson cases, the State must prove intent to defraud — not just that an insurance claim was filed after a fire. Proving intent typically involves evidence of financial distress, recent policy increases, prior suspicious fires, contradictory statements to investigators, or incriminating communications. When the defendant was not in financial distress, the fire’s cause was genuinely ambiguous, and no direct evidence of planning or preparation exists, the intent-to-defraud element is genuinely contestable. I evaluate all financial records and communications in insurance arson cases to determine what the State actually has — versus what they claim.

Frequently Asked Questions — Arson Defense in Florida

What is the penalty for arson in Florida?

Arson of a dwelling under § 806.01(1) is a first-degree felony with up to 30 years in prison. Arson of any other structure under § 806.01(2) is a second-degree felony with up to 15 years, and burning property to defraud an insurer is a separate third-degree felony under § 817.233. If someone is present in the burning structure and is injured, the State may layer attempted murder charges, which carry life imprisonment exposure.

Is burning your own property arson in Florida?

Yes — under § 806.01, burning your own dwelling or structure is arson if it is done willfully and unlawfully (such as with intent to defraud an insurer) or while committing another felony. The fact that you own the property does not provide a defense when the fire is set to collect an insurance payment or to harm another person. Insurance fraud arson is one of the most common arson charges in Florida.

How reliable is fire investigation evidence in arson cases?

Fire investigation evidence has a documented history of unreliability. The 2009 National Academy of Sciences report identified fire investigation as an area where claimed scientific indicators of arson were often unsupported by controlled research. Indicators historically cited as proof of arson — burn patterns, char depth, glass crazing — have been shown to occur in accidental fires. Arson convictions based on these indicators have been overturned. An independent fire science expert is essential in any case where the State’s arson determination is the key evidence.

Can arson charges be filed if no one was hurt and the building was empty?

Yes. Under § 806.01, the type of structure, and what the defendant knew about whether anyone was inside, affect the degree of the charge — but arson can be charged regardless of injury or occupancy. An empty commercial building burned outside normal business hours is generally arson of a structure under § 806.01(2) — a second-degree felony with up to 15 years. Burning an empty dwelling, by contrast, is still first-degree arson. No injury is required, and the structure does not need to be totally destroyed — any damage caused by the fire satisfies the damage element.

What is the difference between arson and attempted murder in Florida when someone is injured in a fire?

When a person is present in a burning structure and suffers serious bodily injury or is killed, the State will typically charge both arson and attempted murder (§ 782.04) or felony murder. Felony murder under § 782.04(1)(a)2 applies when a person dies during the commission of arson — making the arsonist responsible for first-degree murder regardless of intent to kill. This combination — arson plus felony murder — is one of the most serious charging patterns in Florida and can result in mandatory life imprisonment.

Facing Arson Charges in Polk County?

Fire investigation science has put innocent people in prison. You need a lawyer who will challenge the methodology.

Board Certified in Criminal Trial Law by The Florida Bar · Reach Us 24/7 · Hablamos Español

CALL NOW: (863) 774-4556 FREE CONSULTATION

Fire Investigation Expert Testimony: Challenging the Science

Arson prosecutions rest almost entirely on expert testimony from fire investigators — typically sheriff’s office fire marshals or state fire investigators employed by the Florida State Fire Marshal’s Office. These investigators use methodology developed by the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA 921) to determine the origin and cause of a fire. But NFPA 921 methodology is often applied inconsistently, and many fire investigators rely on discredited “indicators” of arson — V-patterns, pour patterns, low burn marks, concrete spalling — that modern fire science has shown can also result from accidental fires. I retain independent fire investigation experts certified by the International Association of Arson Investigators (IAAI) who can scrutinize the State’s methodology, challenge negative corpus reasoning (the fire must have been set because we ruled out all accidental causes), and present an alternative origin and cause theory to the jury. Without a defense expert in an arson case, you are letting the State’s expert testify unchallenged — that is not a defense strategy.

Insurance Fraud Arson: The Paper Trail Defense

Burning to defraud an insurer under § 817.233 is a third-degree felony carrying up to 5 years, and when the property is a dwelling the State can also charge first-degree arson under § 806.01(1). The State typically proves insurance fraud arson through: the insurance policy and recent increases in coverage, financial hardship records (mortgage defaults, credit card delinquency, business debt), statements made to insurance adjusters, and cell phone location data placing the defendant at or near the scene. I attack all of it. Insurance claim paperwork can be challenged for authentication and hearsay. Financial records can be contextualized — a struggling business does not mean arson. Cell phone location data from towers is notoriously imprecise at short distances. And the fire investigation itself remains subject to the same expert challenge described above. These cases are winnable with the right preparation.

Occupied vs. Unoccupied Structures: Why the Distinction Matters

Under § 806.01, Florida draws a sharp penalty distinction based on the kind of structure and on occupancy, but the test is not whether someone was actually inside at the time of the fire. Arson of any dwelling, occupied or not, is a first-degree felony carrying up to 30 years, and so is arson of a structure where people are normally present (for businesses, churches, and schools, during normal hours of occupancy) or of any other structure the defendant knew or had reasonable grounds to believe was occupied. Arson of other structures is a second-degree felony with up to 15 years. No first-degree category requires proof that a person was actually inside. In cases involving commercial buildings or fires set after business hours, whether the building was one where people are normally present at that time, and what the defendant knew or had reason to believe about occupancy, are genuinely contestable. If the State cannot prove one of the first-degree categories, the charge is second-degree, not first — a difference of 15 years in sentencing exposure.

Attempted Arson

Under § 806.01 combined with Florida’s attempt statute at § 777.04, attempted arson is charged when the fire was set but did not ignite the structure, or when law enforcement intercepted the attempt before completion. Attempted arson of an occupied structure is attempted first-degree felony arson — still a second-degree felony carrying up to 15 years. The attempt charge requires proof of a specific intent to set fire to the structure and an overt act in furtherance of that intent. Cases involving accelerants found near a structure but no actual fire are frequently charged as attempted arson, and those cases often turn on whether the defendant’s presence and possession of accelerants proves specific intent beyond a reasonable doubt — which is a fact question for a jury.

Accelerant Evidence: Chain of Custody and Laboratory Issues

In most arson prosecutions, the State’s physical evidence centers on accelerant detection — samples taken from the fire scene, analyzed at a laboratory using gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS), and compared against a library of known accelerants. Accelerant evidence is subject to multiple defense challenges: (1) chain of custody — who collected the sample, how it was packaged, stored, and transported to the lab; (2) contamination — many accelerants occur naturally in building materials, furniture, and flooring, and a positive result for petroleum distillates does not necessarily mean arson; (3) laboratory methodology — the comparison database and analytical technique must meet Daubert reliability standards; (4) sample degradation — exposure to water, heat, and weathering can alter or destroy accelerant residue, making the absence of evidence inconclusive in either direction. I have successfully challenged accelerant evidence at the Daubert hearing level in Florida courts — excluding the evidence before it ever reached the jury.

Related Practice Areas

Board Certified. 75+ Jury Trials. Available Now.

The Rodriguez Law Office defends arson charges throughout the 10th Judicial Circuit — Polk, Highlands, and Hardee Counties.

Board Certified · Reach Us 24/7 · Hablamos Español

CALL NOW: (863) 774-4556 FREE CONSULTATION